norseman Posted Tuesday at 08:26 PM Admin Author Posted Tuesday at 08:26 PM 57 minutes ago, MIB said: Lets pause and consider this statement. There can't be two truths. If the "average human" has incomplete knowledge, they have fundamentally wrong knowledge .. because the knowledge has to be complete to be correct. .. then the other angle. That high level academic, if being honest, KNOWS their own knowledge is incomplete and their current assessment will be replaced. (Dang, that looks like the pattern of Dunning Kruger vs imposter syndrome!) One of the surprises is that the DNA evidence says that descendants of those early out of africa -> europe folks went back to africa, re-integrated, then left Africa again for Europe, and re-integrated again. In other words, it was not merely multiple waves coming out of Africa at different times, but returns from the places are imbedded within the DNA from Africa that came out later. It's pretty freakin' cool .. unless you're after a simple story. Then it's probably pretty frustrating. Agreed. And the two truths that collided in Academia was the field of DNA versus Archaeology. Most of our understanding of history came from fossil hunters. It’s only very recently that DNA has gotten good enough to challenge accepted norms in archaeology. There is no way we could have known that modern Europeans carried Neanderthal DNA. In the 1800s science considered a Neanderthal as something almost akin to a Gorilla. We now know this to be ridiculous. Boy the joke was on them!
georgerm Posted Thursday at 05:11 PM Posted Thursday at 05:11 PM On 11/17/2026 at 11:21 AM, MIB said: One of the surprises is that the DNA evidence says that descendants of those early out of africa -> europe folks went back to africa, re-integrated, then left Africa again for Europe, and re-integrated again. In other words, it was not merely multiple waves coming out of Africa at different times, but returns from the places are imbedded within the DNA from Africa that came out later. Can you please explain where this reintegration theory came from and who proposed it. I have been reading about one theory that describes Homo erectus over thousands of years it migrated north and gradually left Africa and reestablished itself Europe.
MIB Posted Friday at 02:57 PM Admin Posted Friday at 02:57 PM The theory came from the DNA. Look up Eurasian back-migrations. It is not just one person's idea. Look at the bottom of the page for the citations and authors. Pretty extensive. 1 1
norseman Posted Friday at 04:46 PM Admin Author Posted Friday at 04:46 PM 23 hours ago, georgerm said: Can you please explain where this reintegration theory came from and who proposed it. I have been reading about one theory that describes Homo erectus over thousands of years it migrated north and gradually left Africa and reestablished itself Europe. It became Homo Antecessor in Europe. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homo_antecessor And it possibly become several species in Asia. Such as, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homo_luzonensis The DNA study is ongoing. But it looks like much interbreeding occurred between all of these species of Homo. 1
MIB Posted Friday at 05:47 PM Admin Posted Friday at 05:47 PM 49 minutes ago, norseman said: But it looks like much interbreeding occurred between all of these species of Homo. That, in turn, means that a different definition of "species" is being used when describing genus Homo than is used for every other species. (Ok, we're a bit sloppy with canids and a few other domesticated things as well.) By the standard definition, if two critters can produce offspring which can also reproduce, they are the same species, not separate species. So in the most precise use of the word, what we're calling neanderthal and Denisovan are not actually a different species than us because we successfully interbred. If it had been done correctly, applying the nomenclature properly, we'd all be Homo "something". It'd be something like H. "something" sapiens, H. "something" neanderthal, and H. "something" denisovan. The early scientists who did the naming made some invalid assumptions about biological uniqueness and instead gave the names based on morphology, not on biological compatibility. Now we have a mess. Interesting side note: I was actually going to provide the full nomenclature for neanderthal and denisovan but found that there is not currently a globally accepted species name for denisovan. Hmmm. I learn new stuff every day whether it is useful or not.
norseman Posted Friday at 10:51 PM Admin Author Posted Friday at 10:51 PM 4 hours ago, MIB said: That, in turn, means that a different definition of "species" is being used when describing genus Homo than is used for every other species. (Ok, we're a bit sloppy with canids and a few other domesticated things as well.) By the standard definition, if two critters can produce offspring which can also reproduce, they are the same species, not separate species. So in the most precise use of the word, what we're calling neanderthal and Denisovan are not actually a different species than us because we successfully interbred. If it had been done correctly, applying the nomenclature properly, we'd all be Homo "something". It'd be something like H. "something" sapiens, H. "something" neanderthal, and H. "something" denisovan. The early scientists who did the naming made some invalid assumptions about biological uniqueness and instead gave the names based on morphology, not on biological compatibility. Now we have a mess. Interesting side note: I was actually going to provide the full nomenclature for neanderthal and denisovan but found that there is not currently a globally accepted species name for denisovan. Hmmm. I learn new stuff every day whether it is useful or not. Well kinda. There is DNA evidence with Neanderthal genes that no Y male chromosomes survive. So that means that either male hybrids didn’t survive or they were sterile. Think Mule or Liger here. So while a Horse and a Donkey or a Lion and a Tiger have common ancestors and are closely related? They still have enough gene drift to have reproductive problems in offspring. https://www.hhmi.org/news/when-populations-collide 1
guyzonthropus Posted 20 minutes ago Posted 20 minutes ago Basing our knowledge upon the fossil record is difficult due to just how much is missing from it. If you look at just how how few we have of the hominid lineage its hardly a complete picture. There were undoubtedly a larger number of "players" that never fossilized, or have yet to be discovered, than the number of specimens we do have. We have nothing close to a complete understanding of where we or other species arose from. MIB has it right in his statement that the evolution of forms(species) can occur much faster than than the standard take on Darwinian evolution where the gradual accumulation of minor mutations eventually result in a platypus. Environments of dynamic stressors will prove more Selective than stable habitats, thereby fueling a faster pace of differentiation and speciation. However his noting of seemingly disparate definitions of species is a bit off, but yeah, the term needs upgrading. Because not only are there a variety of vertebrate species which can hybridize and produce fertile offspring,, its been proven out to occur between two different genera(genus's) as well. And while that shouldn't be possible between species, it really shouldn't be possible between two genus!! And if incomplete knowledge is inherently wrong then we stand no chance for when is knowledge ever complete? Science strives to compile ever more complete models of existence, but I don't think anyone seriously thinks that some day we'll have "it all down"
Recommended Posts