I posted this as part of a reply to ShadowBorn in another thread, but figured that I would put it hear in Field Trips.
We seem to have more luck finding activity in the area of old abandoned settlements in this region. There were a lot of little settlements that dotted the area but were abandoned in the early 1900s. Even if no trace of the buildings exist you can still find flat areas where old dirt roads once were.
These places are hard to get to and aren't on any map or trail. We stumble across them crisscrossing the forests here.
We were in Devil's Creek looking around yesterday. Unlike other settlements that were abandoned when the land was taken over by the government for the creation of national or state forests, this area was voluntarily abandoned in the late 1940s for some reason. That abandonment, coupled with the strange names found there (Devil's Creek, Hell's Hollow, Booger Hollow), is why we decided to explore it. This building is a bit more preserved than what we usually find. It was accessible to hikers until about ten years ago, so there was a ton of old graffiti on it...the latest being dated 2012. People would hike in via a rail line and bridge, but the bridge was closed off a decade ago.
The hikes in and out were brutal. There was an old long unused trail that was nothing but loose large rocks that we found mentioned on an old blog discussing the history of the area. We cut through the woods a few miles and found the spot. Hiking out over the rocks was punishing, especially considering that we have been exploring the areas just a few miles off of old gravel roads for the past few months. I have gotten soft. My body feels like I have been beaten by a baseball bat.
Very, very interesting area, though. There supposedly is an old cemetery that was still somewhat visible ten years ago, but we didn't find it before we lost light. We usually do most of our investigating at night, but chose not to spend the night there. We will return there soon.